Rising Property Insurance Costs in Central Florida: What Vacation Homeowners Need to Know

real estate market

Owning a vacation home in Central Florida’s highly sought-after counties—Osceola, Polk, and Lake—has been a rewarding investment for many. However, with the ongoing surge in property insurance costs, the financial dynamics of owning a vacation property are changing significantly.

The Current Insurance Landscape

Florida leads the nation in property insurance premiums, with rates skyrocketing by 72% over the past five years. Currently, the average premium in the state is approximately $11,759 annually, compared to a national average of about $1,700. This disparity is driven by Florida’s susceptibility to hurricanes, severe storms, and other natural disasters.

Where Insurance Rates Are Headed

Experts predict continued increases in insurance costs for homeowners in Florida:

  • 2024 Projections: A national average increase of 6% is expected, but Florida rates could climb much higher due to ongoing risks and the struggles of the state’s insurance market.
  • Long-Term Trends: Insurers are becoming more selective, raising premiums, and in some cases, pulling out of the Florida market entirely. This makes it likely that homeowners will see higher costs with fewer coverage options.

Impact on Property Values and Buyer Demand

As insurance premiums rise, several key trends are affecting vacation homeowners:

  • Reduced Affordability for Buyers: Elevated insurance costs add to a buyer’s monthly expenses, shrinking the pool of potential buyers.
  • Market Slowdown: Higher costs discourage buyers, leading to longer listing times and downward pressure on vacation home values.
  • Investment Reassessment: Some buyers are shifting their focus to states with lower carrying costs, potentially impacting demand in Central Florida.

Is Now the Time to Sell?

With predictions of a deeper market correction of up to 25% in Osceola and Polk Counties by mid to late 2025, many vacation homeowners are weighing the benefits of selling now versus holding onto their properties. Selling before further market shifts may allow you to maximize your returns, avoid future losses, and move your investment into more stable opportunities.

How We Can Help

At Vacay & Co Real Estate, we specialize in helping vacation homeowners like you navigate the unique challenges of the Central Florida market. Whether you’re looking to sell or simply want to understand your property’s current market value, we’re here to provide expert guidance every step of the way.


Contact Us Today!

Don’t wait to make an informed decision about your investment property. Call us now at 321-333-1338, email us at [email protected], or visit our Marketing Page to learn more about how we can help you achieve your goals.

Maximize your investment today and secure your financial future tomorrow! 🚀